| James A. Murray | 2023-2024 |
| Eric E. Husebo | 2022-2023 |
| Russell E. Robbins | 2021-2022 |
| Jayme K. Baker, Sr. | 2020-2021 |
| Erich F. Horgan | 2019-2020 |
| David L. Hill | 2018-2019 |
| Jeramie D. Hammond | 2017-2018 |
| Ralph H. Bartlett | 2016-2017 |
| Peter J. Yazzie | 2015-2016 |
| Otis L. Jackson | 2014-2015 |
| Steven R. Silva | 2013-2014 |
| Jayme K. Baker | 2012-2013 |
| Stephen S. Goddu | 2011-2012 |
| Kevin A. Thayer | 2010-2011 |
| E. David Doe * | 2009-2010 |
| Sean E. LeBlanc (a,g) | 2008-2009 |
| Donald A. Lans | 2007-2008 |
| Brian D. Baker (s) | 2006-2007 |
| Gary E. Travis | 2005-2006 |
| Glenn J. Barkley | 2004-2005 |
| John E. (Ted) Huguenin * | 2003-2004 |
| James M. Howe * | 2002-2003 |
| Michael D. Bailow (s,c) | 2001-2002 |
| Arne Grepstad (a,b,c,f) | 2000-2001 |
| William R. Chaston | 1999-2000 |
| Peter R. Colgan | 1998-1999 |
| William R. Sproles | 1997-1998 |
| Sidney L. Bearon (J,c,a) | 1995-1996 |
| Alan R. DeRemer | 1995 |
| Steven M. Loyd | 1994 |
| Robert A. Greenfield * | 1993 |
| Robert A. Walker * | 1992,1997 |
| Richard W. Seychew (c) | 1991 |
| Edgar L. Kleindinst (f) | 1990 |
| Willard A. Plummer (c) | 1989 |
| Rodney O. Thrasher * | 1988 |
| Donald G. Fuller * (c) | 1987 |
| Clifford C. Goehring * | 1986 |
| Andras J. Nyari (b) | 1985 |
| E. Joel Peterson (h,b,c,g,a,m) | 1984 |
| Kenneth R. Ilg | 1983 |
| J. Paul Thompson | 1981,1982 |
| Ralph R. Romkey | 1980 |
| Frederick F. Jones * | 1979 |
| Charles A. Peterman (a,b,c) | 1978 |
| George A. Marken * (c) | 1977 |
| Stephen L. Baker (c) | 1976 |
| James A. Stevens * | 1975 |
| Harold W. Hammond * | 1974 |
| Kenneth C. Smith * | 1971,1972 |
| Alfred G. Irish * | 1970 |
| Elisha Robbins * (c,g) | 1969 |
| Joseph P. Gerace * | 1968 |
| F. Gordon Jaynes * (c,p) | 1967 |
| Howard R. Delano * (a) | 1966 |
| Rollin A. Kirtley, Jr. * | 1965 |
| Evan W. Moore * | 1963 |
| Richard C. Baker * (c) | 1962,1964 |
| Robert C. Tait * (c,f) | 1961 |
| Frederick W. Wormelle * | 1960 |
| Frank L. Nickerson * | 1959 |
| Robert J. Tilden * † | 1958 |
| Russell H. Brown * (c) | 1957 |
| Sumner G. Baker * | 1956 |
| Roger L. Savery * (c) | 1955 |
| Samuel H. Wright * | 1954 |
| George H. Potter * | 1953 |
| Harold L. Baker, Jr. * | 1952,1973 |
| Ray D. Wells, Jr. * | 1951 |
| C. Edward Hall * (c) | 1950 |
| William W. Peters * | 1949 |
| George H. Bigelow * | 1948 |
| Gustave E. Anderson * | 1946 |
| Milton E. Williamson * (a,c) | 1944,1945 |
| Harry L. Crooks * | 1943 |
| Delmar R. Jenkins * | 1942 |
| Joseph R. Hall * (a,c) | 1940,1941 |
| Arnold W. Dyer * | 1938,1939 |
| Samuel A. Smith * (c) | 1937 |
| Cornelius P. Van Tol * | 1936 |
| Richard H. Hopkins * | 1935 |
| John Donald * | 1934 |
| Leroy S. Davis * | 1933 |
| Charles F. Holden * (a,c) | 1932 |
| William Chambers * | 1931,1947 |
| Milford R. Lawrence * | 1930 |
| Charles E. L. Gifford * (c) | 1929 |
| Charles F. Miller * | 1928 |
| Arthur G. Cushman * | 1927 |
| Sumner I. Lawrence * (a,c) | 1926 |
| Rawson C. Jenkins * (a) | 1925 |
| John M. Howe * | 1924 |
| Sidney W. Lawrence * | 1923 |
| J. Edward Nickerson * | 1921,1922 |
| Austin F. Lawrence * | 1919,1920 |
| Howard L. Pierce * | 1917,1918 |
| George H. Greene * | 1915,1916 |
| Leonard R. Parkinson * | 1914 |
| Levi H. Howes * | 1912,1913 |
| James Nicol * | 1910,1911 |
| Amasa W. Baxter * | 1908,1909 |
| Charles A. Bailey * | 1906,1907 |
| Asa L. Pattee * (a) | 1904,1905 |
| Cranston F. Godfrey * | 1903 |
| Leland B. Lane * | 1902 |
| Edward A. Bragg * | 1900,1901 |
| Henry C. Googins * | 1898,1899 |
| Andrew W. Davis * | 1896,1897 |
| Levi A. Howes * | 1894,1895 |
| George A. Merrithew * | 1892,1893 |
| Prince D. Swift * | 1888-1890 |
| Browning Swift * | 1886,1887,1891 |
| George W. Fish * | 1883-1885 |
| William H. Hewins * (a) | 1879-1881 |
| Charles E. Davis * | 1877,1878,1882 |
| Almon P. Sturgis * | 1874-1876 |
| Erasmus Gould * | 1870,1871 |
| Joshua C. Robinson * | 1866-1868, 1872, 1873 |
| William Hewins * | 1861-1865,1869 |
| Benjamin F. Tucker * | 1859,1860 |
| George W. Donaldson * | 1858 |
| George W. Swift * | 1857 |
| DARK | 1833-1856 |
| unknown | 1830-1833 |
| Aaron Cornish * | 1824-1829 |
| DARK | 1810-1821 |
| Timothy Parker * | 1809 |
| Major Hatch * | 1807 |
| Joseph Percival * | 1806 |
| Elijah Swift * | 1800,1803-1805,1821-1823 |
| Frank Wicks * | 1798,1799,1801,1802,1808 |
